2015年ACCA《公司法与商法》精选试题及答案
来源:才华咖 本文已影响3.15W人
来源:才华咖 本文已影响3.15W人
Question:
Apt Ltd is a small independent book company, which specialises in publishing modern poetry. In January 2013 itsigned a contract with a new poet, called Bel, to publish her second book of poems in August 2014. In March 2013, Bel won a prestigious award for her first book of poems, which had been published privately.
In the light of the fame which now attached to Bel, Apt Ltd launched an extensive advertising campaign publicising the forthcoming book. The campaign was expensive, costing £50,000, but it was successful in generating great interest. As a result, Apt Ltd won a contract to supply a large book club with 100,000 copies of the book, which would make them a profit of £250,000.
Unfortunately in May 2014, Bel informed Apt Ltd that she would not be able to supply the manuscript to it as she had signed a more rewarding contract with Cax plc, a very large publishing company.
Required:
In the context of Bel’s anticipatory breach of contract, explain any possible remedies open to Apt Ltd.
Answer:
The essential issues to be disentangled from the problem scenario relate to breach of contract and the remedies available for such breach.
There is clearly a binding contractual agreement between Art Ltd and Bel, which Bel has stated she intends to break. Normally breach of a contract occurs where one of the parties to the agreement fails to comply, either completely or satisfactorily, with their obligations under it. However, such a definition does not appear to apply in this case as the time has not yet come when Bel has to produce the manuscript. She has merely indicated that she has no intention of doing so. This is an example of the operation of the doctrine of anticipatory breach. This arises precisely where one party, prior to the actual due date of performance, demonstrates an intention not to perform their contractual obligations. The intention not to fulfil the contract can be either express or implied.
Express anticipatory breach occurs where a party actually states that they will not perform their contractual obligations (Hochster v De La Tour (1853)). Implied anticipatory breach occurs where a party carries out some act which makes performance impossible (Omnium Enterprises v Sutherland (1919)).
When anticipatory breach takes place, the innocent party can sue for damages immediately on receipt of the notification of the other party’s intention to repudiate the contract, without waiting for the actual contractual date of performance as in Hochster v De La Tour. Alternatively, they can wait until the actual time for performance before taking action. In the latter instance, they are entitled to make preparations for performance, and claim the agreed contract price (White and Carter (Councils) v McGregor (1961)).
It would appear that Bel’s action is clearly an instance of express anticipatory breach and that Art Ltd has the right either to accept the repudiation immediately, or affirm the contract and take action against Bel at the time for performance (Vitol SA v Norelf Ltd (1996)). In any event, Bel is bound to complete her contractual promise or suffer the consequences of her breach of contract.
Remedies for breach of contract
(i) Specific performance
It will sometimes suit a party to break their contractual obligations, even if they have to pay damages. In such circumstances, the court can make an order for specific performance to require the party in breach to complete their part of the contract. However, as specific performance is not available in respect of contracts of employment or personal service, Bel cannot be legally required to provide the manuscript to Apt Ltd (Ryan v Mutual Tontine Westminster Chambers Association (1893)). This means that the only remedy against Bel lies in the award of damages.
(ii) Damages
A breach of contract will result in the innocent party being able to sue for damages. Apt Ltd, therefore, can sue Bel for damages, but the important issue relates to the extent of such damages.
ACCA《财务会计》真题及答案
2016年ACCA F5考试真题及答案「完整版」
2016年ACCA考试《会计师与企业》模拟试题
2016年ACCA F6(CHN)考试真题及答案「完整版」
2016年12月ACCA考试F4精选习题及答案
全国计算机二级《Access》单选试题及答案2016
2016年计算机二级《Access》测试题及答案
2016年12月ACCA考试F4最新模拟题及答案
2016年12月ACCA考试F4练习题及答案
2015年ACCA《公司法与商法》训练试题
2016年ACCA考试用什么笔-ACCA常见问题
2016年ACCA考试《F8审计与认证业务》冲刺试题
2016年12月ACCA考试P1模拟试题及答案
2015年ACCA《公司法与商法》练习试题
2016年ACCA考试内容有哪些-ACCA常见问题
2016计算机二级《Access》考试预测题及答案
2016计算机二级考试《Access》预测题及答案
《公司法》试题及答案
2016计算机二级《Access》考试试题及答案
2016年12月ACCA考试F4冲刺练习及答案
2016计算机二级《Access》选择题题库及答案
ACCA考试技巧与学习方法2017
2016计算机二级《Access》操作试题及答案
2016计算机二级《Access》冲刺试题及答案
全国计算机二级《Access》自测试题与答案2017
2016计算机二级《Access》自测试题与答案
民法典知识试题及答案
2017计算机二级《Access》考试试题及答案
2017年CCNA认证试题及答案
2016计算机二级《Access》选择题练习及答案
2015年司法考试《商法》专项练习题及答案
2017计算机二级《Access》考试题及答案
《人民警察法》试题及答案
计算机二级《Access》考试模拟试题及答案2017
计算机二级《Access》备考试题及答案2016
2016年12月ACCA考试F4模拟练习及答案
2016年ACCA(P3)考试模拟真题答案
2015年ACCA《公司法与商法》精选试题及答案
ACCA P5模拟考试题及答案
计算机二级《Access》备考试题与答案2016